Editor-in-Chief Desk Decision
nounPronunciation: /ˌɛdɪtər ɪn tʃiːf dɛsk dɪˈsɪʒən/
A final editorial determination made by the Editor-in-Chief to accept, reject, or request revisions for a manuscript based on reviewer feedback and editorial assessment. This decision represents the highest editorial authority and is binding without further review.
Plain English
The final decision by the Editor-in-Chief to accept, reject, or revise a manuscript after reviewing all feedback.
Etymology & History
Usage
"The manuscript received an Editor-in-Chief desk decision rejecting it due to limited scope despite positive reviewer feedback."
Style guide notes: Capitalize 'Editor-in-Chief' when referring to the specific position; hyphenate 'desk decision' consistently.
Also known as
Contrasted with
Related Terms
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an Editor-in-Chief desk decision be appealed?
Most journals have appeal processes, but the Editor-in-Chief decision carries significant weight and rarely changes upon appeal.
What factors influence an Editor-in-Chief desk decision?
Reviewer feedback, manuscript scope, journal fit, ethical considerations, and novelty all influence the final editorial decision.
Why Test Candidates on This?
Essential for understanding editorial hierarchy and the decision-making process that determines manuscript publication outcomes.
Required skill level: Senior