Editorial advisory consultation
nounPronunciation: /ˌɛdɪˈtɔːriəl ədˈvaɪzəri kənˌsʌlˈteɪʃən/
A formal or informal process where the editor-in-chief or handling editor seeks guidance from senior editorial board members or subject matter experts on complex manuscript decisions. This consultation typically addresses borderline accept/reject decisions, methodological concerns, or policy interpretations.
Plain English
When editors ask experienced colleagues for advice on difficult decisions about whether to accept, reject, or request revisions for a manuscript.
Etymology & History
Usage
"The editor initiated an editorial advisory consultation with two board members regarding the controversial statistical methodology."
Style guide notes: Use 'consultation' rather than 'consult session'; specify whether advisory input is binding or recommendatory in policy descriptions.
Also known as
Contrasted with
Related Terms
Frequently Asked Questions
When is editorial advisory consultation typically requested?
For borderline decisions, methodological disputes, or when policy interpretation affects manuscript outcomes.
Are editorial advisory consultations documented?
Documentation varies by journal, but consultation summaries may be retained in manuscript records for audit purposes.
Why Test Candidates on This?
Relevant for senior editorial positions and understanding escalation procedures for complex or contentious manuscript decisions.
Required skill level: Senior