Editorial gatekeeping
nounPronunciation: /ˌɛdɪtɔːrɪəl ˈɡeɪtˌkiːpɪŋ/
The editor's responsibility to maintain journal quality and standards by controlling which manuscripts enter the peer review process. This function protects reviewers' time and preserves the journal's reputation and credibility.
Plain English
The editor's role in deciding which submissions deserve peer review based on quality and relevance standards.
Etymology & History
Usage
"Strong editorial gatekeeping ensures that only methodologically sound studies reach the peer review stage."
Style guide notes: Gatekeeping can be presented as either a positive (quality control) or negative (exclusionary) function depending on context.
Also known as
Contrasted with
Related Terms
Frequently Asked Questions
What criteria do editors use for gatekeeping decisions?
Editors evaluate scope fit, methodological rigor, novelty, and compliance with author guidelines.
Does gatekeeping delay publication timelines?
While gatekeeping adds review time, it reduces reviewer burden and ultimately accelerates overall publication processes.
Why Test Candidates on This?
Essential for understanding editorial authority and journal quality maintenance mechanisms.
Required skill level: Senior