Editorial Decision Letter Composition
nounPronunciation: /ˌɛdɪˈtɔːriəl dɪˈsɪʒən ˈlɛtər kɒmpəˈzɪʃən/
The structured preparation of formal communications from editors to authors regarding manuscript review outcomes, including rationale for decisions and reviewer feedback summaries. This critical document maintains scholarly standards while providing constructive guidance for revision or resubmission.
Plain English
Writing the official email from the editor telling an author whether their paper is accepted, rejected, or needs changes.
Etymology & History
Usage
"Effective editorial decision letter composition requires balancing honesty with encouragement to maintain author relations."
Style guide notes: Use 'decision letter' for brevity; maintain consistent tone and terminology across all editorial communications.
Also known as
Contrasted with
Related Terms
Frequently Asked Questions
Should editors disclose all reviewer comments in decision letters?
Most journals summarize feedback without disclosing reviewers' identities; some allow full comment disclosure with approval.
How detailed should rejection rationales be?
Rejection letters should explain decision reasoning and identify specific weaknesses while remaining professional and constructive.
Why Test Candidates on This?
Critical skill for editors and editorial managers responsible for author communications and relationship management.
Required skill level: Senior