Editorial desk reject
nounPronunciation: /ˈɛdɪtɔːrɪəl ˈdɛsk rɪˈdʒɛkt/
A rejection decision made by an editor without sending the manuscript to peer review, typically due to poor fit with journal scope, insufficient quality, or failure to meet submission guidelines. Desk rejects are efficient mechanisms to expedite the review process for unsuitable submissions.
Plain English
When an editor rejects a paper immediately without asking reviewers to evaluate it.
Etymology & History
Usage
"The manuscript received an editorial desk reject because the research design did not align with the journal's publication criteria."
Style guide notes: Use 'desk reject' as standard terminology; distinguish clearly from peer-review rejections in decision communications.
Also known as
Contrasted with
Related Terms
Frequently Asked Questions
Why do journals use desk rejects?
To reduce reviewer workload by filtering unsuitable submissions and accelerate review timelines for manuscripts with merit.
Can I appeal an editorial desk reject?
Appeal policies vary by journal; some journals allow appeals with substantive new information or clarifications about scope fit.
Why Test Candidates on This?
Essential for understanding editorial workflow efficiency and commonly included in journal management training materials.
Required skill level: Junior